Homes for sale in Cortland County New York | Page 1 of 6 | Country Homes of America
CountryHomesofAmerica.com
#1 in Rural Real Estate Online

Homes for sale in Cortland County New York - Page 1 of 6

25 photos
$69,000 10.01 acres
3449 Hubbards Hill Road, Taylor, NY 13040 - Cortland County

Beautiful cabin on 10 secluded acres to hunt

Beautiful cabin on 10 wooded and secluded acres on a seasonal road with a meandering stream that borders the property. Great for a family get away or a hunting camp. Cabin is wired and a generator provides electricity. 1 bedroom plus loft sleeps 4 comfortably. Indoor composting toilet. Outdoor shower or wash up in bathroom sink. Wood stove with electric blower is more than enough to handle the cold. This Conestoga Log cabin is well insulated with double-insulated roof and floor as well as a metal roof. 2 skylights, ceiling fan, 6 foot wide side porch. 12 x 18 foot shed with an attached 11ft carport. Roughing it has never been this nice! If you are seeking that ideal getaway site, this property is a must see. Copyright 2019 Greater Syrac
Allen Olmsted Canaan Realty
25 photos
$98,900 40.97 acres
00 Route 41, Willet, NY 13841 - Cortland County

40 acres Waterfront Land on Cincinnatus Lake NY

40 country acres on Cincinnatus Lake in Willet NY, Cortland County. Nice building lot with room to play and an acre on the water. Kayak, canoe or just have a seat and look over the water. The land is currently maintained for farming but with a little work could be an awesome building lot. NY-41 spits the acre on the waterfront from the acreage across the road. Looking for that country acreage to build on? Here it is plus waterfront. Lovely area with other waterfront properties around the lake providing a quaint area for you and yours to enjoy. The waterfront is located at the shallow end of the lake allowing canoes, kayaks or whatever you have. This time of year the water is lowered to prevent ice damage on the lake. Location:
Carl Snyder NY Land Quest, LLC
32 photos
$390,000 249 acres
0 Maxson Road, Preble, NY 13077 - Cortland County

Private pond and cabin with multiple hunting blinds

Nearly 250 acre hunting and recreational hilltop getaway. Pristine cabin on site overlooks the stocked and swimmable pond. Property boasts miles of trails and a number of existing hunting stands. Enjoy hours at this family getaway, snowmobile, or just relax by the pond feeding the fish as you read a good book or prepare for the next day of hunting of exploring. Mixture of hard and softwood stands, ravine with a small stream and waterfall. You will find yourself looking for a day off to enjoy at this retreat setting. Very easy commute, drilled well, and tranquility enhance this local pristine property! Copyright 2019 Greater Syracuse Association of Realtors. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is dee
Allen Olmsted Canaan Realty
43 photos
$699,500 211.48 acres 3 Beds | 3 Baths | 2246 sqft
4099 Piety Ridge Road, Marathon, NY 13803 - Cortland County

Farm and ranch with multiple structures

Immaculate farm and ranch! This spacious 3 bedroom home has been updated from floors to ceilings, adding a large family room with full height stone fireplace. Country kitchen with breakfast room. If you are looking for a country estate property suitable for a variety of farming operations this is an ideal choice. Horse ranch, beef operation, alpaca, or other agricultural or agritourism uses. The 35'x96' main barn is the center for a # of additional buildings to handle a myriad of uses. The 30'x40' fully insulated work shop with 14' ceilings & infloor heat is one example of the 7+ units or buildings on the grounds. Situated on just over 211 acres w. a mix of open fields w/ high tensile fencing to the woods and year round stream. This grand p
Allen Olmsted Canaan Realty
15 photos
$47,500 15.07 acres
3469 Hubbards Hill Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040 - Cortland County

Spacious recreational or hunting camp

Spacious recreational property with an existing camp on site. Ideal for a getaway destination, hunting, and fishing. Off the grid property ideal for solitude! A small frog pond and acres of woods enhance this relaxing property. Camp features kitchen area, a couple couches, room for sleeping and a separate room with camping toilet area. Enjoy spectacular fall colors in one of NY States premiere recreational destinations. Easy access to the camp via road close to the edge of the property. Just a short drive to both Cincinnatus (less than 10 minutes) and Cortland (about a half hour) and less than an hour from Binghamton.
Allen Olmsted Canaan Realty
24 photos
$129,900 79.89 acres
00 Penelope Road, Willet, NY 13863 - Cortland County

79 acres Woodlands and Hay Fields in Willet NY Penelope Road

79 acres Mix of Woodlands and Hay Fields with Great Views in Cortland County. Take a look at this nice country acreage with hay fields, woods and a stream flowing through it on Penelope Road. It has some nice valley views and is part of an old farm with active hay fields and potential building sites. Lots of wildlife here including deer, turkeys, and grouse. While walking this property I saw two of the three! The woods have some decent logging roads for access. This would make a great place to hunt if you were so inclined. Currently in an Agricultural Exemption zone. Close to Route 41. Look at the pictures I took of the topography and views. So pretty. Great spot to build and start your hobby farm, or put a camp/cabin and have your ow
Carl Snyder NY Land Quest, LLC
18 photos
$237,900 127.72 acres
East Keeney, Fabius, NY 13063 - Cortland County

Ryan Tract

New York land completely wooded, timber, stream and trails for sale.  The property is a nice mix of transition from brush & apple to hardwoods down closer to the road to poletimber sized trees in the central portion to more mature timber higher up on the hill.  The forest has been professionally managed for many years, resulting in a quality timber component where thinnings have been made.  The last harvest was made about 5 years ago leaving a beautiful stand of maple and cherry timber on the east end of the property.  Hard maple is the dominant species here accounting for about 60% of the volume.  Cherry, soft maple and ash are the other predominant species with a mix of other species in lesser quantities.  Current timber stocking is e
Brian Bullard Timberland Realty
42 photos
$699,500 211.48 acres 3 Beds | 3 Baths | 2246 sqft
4099 Piety Ridge Road, Marathon, NY 13803 - Cortland County

Immaculate farm and ranch with 3bed home

Immaculate farm and ranch! This spacious 3 bedroom home has been updated from floors to ceilings, adding a large family room with full height stone fireplace. Country kitchen with breakfast room. If you are looking for a country estate property suitable for a variety of farming operations this is an ideal choice. Horse ranch, beef operation, alpaca, or other agricultural or agritourism uses. The 35'x96' main barn is the center for a # of additional buildings to handle a myriad of uses. The 30'x40' fully insulated work shop with 14' ceilings & infloor heat is one example of the 7+ units or buildings on the grounds. Situated on just over 211 acres w. a mix of open fields w/ high tensile fencing to the woods and year round stream. This grand p
Allen Olmsted Canaan Realty
34 photos
$1,375,000 350 acres 4 Beds | 3 Baths | 1 ½ Bath | 4400 sqft
5896 Maxson Road, Homer, NY 13077 - Cortland County

Picturesque hilltop equestrian facility

Unique 350 acre Equestrian and Recreational Estate. Mostly wooded with large open areas for horses. Featuring a spacious 4400 sq ft 4/5 bedroom authentic farmhouse w. 3 levels of living space! Climate controlled by in floor radiant heating system & split zone A/C. The 40'x72' four bay garage/ storage building provides plenty of room for cars, trucks and toys, with a heated workshop. Multiple barns including a 36'x48' barn w. five stalls, wash stall & turn outs. Newly constructed 80'175' arena w. 8 additional stalls. Arena includes a 1600 sf 2 bedroom loft apartment with an open floor plan. Picturesque cabin in the woods overlooks a private, stocked pond, ideal for a quick getaway, family retreat, or hunting base for the trophy hunting found
Allen Olmsted Canaan Realty
35 photos
$978,000 101 acres 4 Beds | 4 Baths | 1 ½ Bath | 4400 sqft
5896 A Maxson Road, Homer, NY 13077 - Cortland County

Immaculate home on

Equestrian estate situated on just over 100 acres. Mix of pastures, fields, woods w. trails throughout. Home features spacious 4400 SF 4/5 bedroom authentic farmhouse with 3 levels of living space. Large eat-in kitchen w. cherry cabinets, soapstone counter tops, first floor master suite, laundry, office, & relaxing formal living room w. gas fireplace. Climate controlled by in-floor radiant heating system & split zone A/C. Enjoy morning coffee while watching the sunrise on the oversized country porch. 40x72 4 bay garage serves as storage for cars, trucks, & toys and includes a heated workshop. Multiple barns, which include a 36x48 5 stall barn w. turnouts and a wash stall and hydrant. Also a newly constructed 80x175 arena with an additional
Allen Olmsted Canaan Realty
16 photos
$750,000 142.1 acres
4192 Telephone Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040 - Cortland County

Spectacular golf and commercial business

Spectacular setting! This family-run property known as Knickerbocker Country Club has been a family run business for two generations. What started out as a dream has become a reality in the well manicured and active country golf club. Banquets, weddings, and golfing provide a relaxing getaway for people near and far. Spacious clubhouse is a perfect spot for lounging and for light dining. Excellent reputation, great location, and tremendous potential to take this to the next level. Fully turnkey operation with maintenance equipment and all owned golf carts included.
Allen Olmsted Canaan Realty
39 photos
$217,900 154.8 acres
7531 Cowles Settlement, Truxton, NY 13158 - Cortland County

Hills Creek

New York land with mixed woods, open, plantations, timber, trails, pond and stream for sale.  The property has a nice matrix of woods, open, transition and pine and spruce plantation, creating ideal habitat conditions for a variety of game and non-game species alike.  Multiple building sites are also available along the abundant road frontage or tucked back in the woods or pines/spruce for either home or camp, providing ample seclusion in a quiet rural area. he majority of the property is forested in varying stages of growth.  The timber has been managed for years and a current updated inventory shows approximately 764,340 boardfeet of timber, International ¼” log rule.  The forest is in good condition and will continue to produce valuable
Brian Bullard Timberland Realty
13 photos
$150,000 125.14 acres
125a Freetown Hoxie Gorge, Cincinnatus, NY 13040 - Cortland County

Ideal recreational or year-round home site

Ideal recreational or year round property, gentle to steep hills with an abundance of wildlife. This choice property offers a level building area across from the wooded hill side. As you walk along this choice property, enjoy the wildlife and hunting opportunities along the way. AS you reach the summit, you will find access to Hoxie Gorge State Forest which nestles along the majority of this large acreage site. Located just minutes South of Cortland and close to Rt 81. This makes for an easy commute to so many local and out of state nature enthusiasts. A must see property. Copyright 2019 Greater Syracuse Association of Realtors. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guara
Allen Olmsted Canaan Realty
10 photos
$240,000 127.86 acres
0 Chapman Road, Homer, NY 13077 - Cortland County

Mixed woods and fields with a stream to hunt

Over 125 acres of mixed woods and fields. Ample frontage along a country road. This gently rising property boasts a beautiful sunrise setting looking down a valley. Existing trails and roadways make traversing this choice property easy! Recreational or year-round home site potential. Located just minutes from downtown Cortland/ Homer with easy access to Route 81, yet in a peacefully secluded location. Enjoy whitetail hunting, snowmobiling, bow hunting, or simply relax with views for miles. Copyright 2019 Greater Syracuse Association of Realtors. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.
Allen Olmsted Canaan Realty
4 photos
$39,900 25.05 acres
Lincklaen Rd, Truxton, NY 13158 - Cortland County

Southern Tier Home or Camp Site

Open, rolling meadows with woodlands all around, this property is located on a quiet, maintained town road with power available. This 25 acre parcel would make a nice site to build a country home or getaway for city dwellers. Close to Mariposa, Peage Hill and Cuyler Hill State Forests for southern tier hunting and hiking. Also within an hours drive to Syracuse, Ithaca, Cazenovia and the Finger Lakes region.
Daniel Christmas Christmas and Associates
1 photos
$105,900 78.9 acres
Lapp Hill Rd, Mcgraw, NY 13101 - Cortland County

000 Lapp Hill Rd

79+ Acres of wooded and open land in Cortland County for a new home, camp or for recreation in the great outdoors. Located on a well maintained, quiet country road, with 750+ ft of road frontage and a 28X56 ft barn. The barn does need work, but once repaired it can be utilized for storage or a camp. An old farm road leads up to a secluded 5 acre open field with scenic views of the valley and the neighboring cropland. There are a number of well maintained trails with an abundance of wildlife throughout the property. Centrally located approx. 40 miles north of Binghamton and 40 miles south of Syracuse with easy access to I-81 for all your shopping and entertainment needs making this a must see property. Owner financing may be available
Frank Bonczkiewicz Personalized Real Estate Solutions
30 photos
$95,940 47.97 acres
0 German Hill Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040 - Cortland County

47.97 Acres with Pond and Woods

With its woods so lovely dark and deep you'll forget the promises you have to keep. Totaling 47.97 acres of flat to rolling land that offers a large private pond, streams and fields too. This property has everything and is loaded with deer and other small game. Build your home and still have the entire back 40+ acres to enjoy. Located in Cincinnatus, NY on a town maintained road with a desirable southern exposure, affording excellent building sites and agricultural acreage too. Perfect for homesteading, hunting, fishing, kayaking, hiking and horse back riding. Within easy proximity to large swaths of state forest as well, for further enjoyments of the outdoors. Take a stroll and get lost in the possibilities.
New York Trophy Properties New York Trophy Properties
5 photos
Auction - Jan 23, 2020 at 10:00 AM 2.35 acres 3 Beds | 1 Bath | 948 sqft
5267 Midlum Rd, Truxton, NY 13158 - Cortland County

Auction #2359

Great investment opportunity! This property will be sold via a live foreclosure auction. The asset will be sold "As Is" and the occupancy status varies. The buyer assumes all responsibility for property condition and occupancy. Auction to be conducted by a third party. Please contact Xome for more information.
20 photos
Auction - Dec 14, 2019 at 8:00 AM 5.01 acres 3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1352 sqft
3717 Freetown Crossing Road, Marathon, NY 13803 - Cortland County

Auction #1164

"PER MOST RECENT INSPECTION, PROPERTY IS BELIEVED TO BE VACANT" Upcoming Auction! Exclusive Xome.com Property. NO BUYER'S PREMIUM! Cash Only Transaction (due to lack of property access). A $300 commission to the buyer's agent for representation (no other agent commissions will be paid on this property). This commission will be paid out after successful close of the transaction. Do not disturb any occupant. It is a criminal offense to trespass on this property. For information and to register to bid on this property, please visit Xome.com. A $500 credit will be applied toward closing costs on cash transactions where the purchaser elects to use the seller's title company. *** Foreclosure deed was recorded on 5/20/2019 ***
22 photos
$149,500 45.63 acres 3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1 ½ Bath | 1932 sqft
3907 Hobart Hill Road, Cortland, NY 13045 - Cortland County

45.63 acres Cortland, NY

A rare opportunity awaits, small farmette only minutes from City of Cortland and Route 81 for easy access to Syracuse, Binghamton and only 3 hrs from the GW. This farmhouse boldly sits on a hillside with fantastic distant views, and the acreage is rather flat and terraced. The home itself features large dining and living rooms making it great for any size gathering, and views from almost any room. The 45 acres are mostly open fields, currently hayed but small patch of woods does exist, and small apple orchard. Such a versatile property where you can just enjoy the home, acres and barns or it would be great for raising animals or crops. Call now to see this home, barns and property. Copyright 2019 Greater Syracuse Association of Realtors
22 photos
$109,900 100 acres
00 Elm Street, Cortland, NY 13045 - Cortland County

100 acres Cortland, NY

Amazing property loaded with deer just outside of the Village of McGraw, NY. All-wooded 100 acres has trails throughout with a swale field full of deer trails. HUNTING LAND! Look through the pictures to see if you spot the nice buck that was there when I walked the property. Logging roads that run through the woods offering great access. Come take a walk and look at this acreage in person, you will get the same vibe I did. The land is diverse with low areas of swale and thicket, then gullies and rolling hardwoods. The property was recently logged and left in great shape. It is amazing how secluded you feel. It would be a great destination to call your hunting spot. ATV access on the logging roads and a nice driveway already in place. C
17 photos
$64,000 2.44 acres 2 Beds | 2 Baths | 1 ½ Bath | 1280 sqft
2597 State Route 26, Cincinnatus, NY 13040 - Cortland County

2.44 acres Cincinnatus, NY

You're going to love this privately located property situated high on 2.44 acres. Enter through the back door mudroom to leave your boots and coats. Spacious kitchen and dining room lead to French doors. Spend time entertaining or relaxing on the full front deck while soaking up the amazing views. Enjoy sitting around the approximately 5 year old rice coal stove and the foam insulation in the ceiling and floors help keep your costs down. 2 large bedrooms and the master has a toilet and laundry room. The metal roof is only 3 years old and the hot water heater is approximately 2 years old. Plenty of room in the full basement for a workshop or storage. Come check out this diamond in the rough and make it your own! Copyright 2019 Greater Sy
36 photos
$79,900 64 acres
00 Cincinnatus Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040 - Cortland County

64 acres Cincinnatus, NY

Nice 64 acre property just outside Cincinnatus, NY. Great hunting parcel full of deer and turkeys.Fields and woods that offer amazing views.Perfect spot to put a cabin and enjoy the acreage, or for your very own private hunting area. As you go back off the road it gets wider and opens up.It starts as hay fields and former pasture and then turns into woods.The area is truly full of wildlife sign, in fact, I just about stepped on a fawn while taking pictures. A nice road takes you through the property and allows access. As you go back in the topography goes slowly uphill and allows for amazing views. This area of New York has much to do for the outdoor folks.Otselic River nearby with public access for fishing.Tons of NY State Land around as w
34 photos
$399,000 28 acres 5 Beds | 4 Baths | 2 ½ Baths | 3136 sqft
5361 Route 11, Homer, NY 13077 - Cortland County

28 acres Homer, NY

Views say it all. Welcome to this beautiful 5 bedroom, 2 full 2 1/2 baths. Located just outside the Homer Village. Wide open kithchen/living room, with sliding doors to amazing deck and views. 28 amazing acres with 2 beautiful manmade ponds on both sides, great for kayaking, swimming, hiking, and great get togethers. 2 car garage with upstairs storage. SO much to enjoy, a vacation everyday!!! Take a walk outback across the railroad tracks and find another pond. This is a must see to believe!! Just 30 minutes from Ithaca, Close to 81 and Syracuse. Make your appt. today!!! Copyright 2019 Ithaca Board of Realtors. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and shoul
25 photos
$149,900 45.2 acres 4 Beds | 1 Bath | 1968 sqft
5948 Forshee Road, Willet, NY 13863 - Cortland County

45.2 acres Willet, NY

Welcome to this terrific one of a kind home located on a secluded and idyllic 45 acres! If you are looking for privacy and energy independence then look no further! This year-round home features a wonderful floor plan with open floor concept. You'll love the kitchen with natural wood countertops and wood stove for heating and cooking. Features include four bedrooms upstairs with a living room and dining room on the first floor. There is also a separate bonus room on the first floor equip with a cozy wood stove and sink. You'll enjoy the bungalow next tot he pond that could be your own retreat or hobby space. Electric is provided by a 48 volt solar panel system (all owned). For the right buyer, this is a lifetime opportunity to own a custom
25 photos
$108,900 50 acres
5965 Pease Hill Road, Cuyler, NY 13158 - Cortland County

50 acres Cuyler, NY

Location means everything and this property has it! Surrounded by 3 areas of NY State Forest.Nice two story 24 x 24 unfinished cabin on 50 acres of NY's finest.Property has electric and is fully insulated. Hunt deer, ducks, turkey or just sit back and enjoy.Exterior of building is complete. Easily accessible from I-81 or NY-13, this spot is for outdoor people.The cabin is on a mowed area that slopes down to the beaver pond where you can see ducks and geese.The large woodlot section rises up and there is a second access point down a deeded right-of-way just up the road.Quiet area, nice country setting.Bottom land has apples and beaver pond. Wood stove, nice kitchen area. Ski resorts, ATVs and snowmobiles, public fishing access.Explore nearb
56 photos
$299,900 56.03 acres 3 Beds | 1 Bath | 972 sqft
2246 Gee Hill Rd., Virgil, NY 13053 - Cortland County

56.03 acres Virgil, NY

Lovely secluded ranch-style home, pond, and 56 acres for sale near Dryden, NY in Cortland Co. Nice 3 bd/1 ba home w/hardwood floors, tongue & groove pine on ceilings/walls w/spectacular stone fireplace. Far from any neighbors! Nicely updated/remodeled home overlooking 1/2 fish pond, w/ a screened-in porch and outdoor deck. Cedar siding, well, septic, electric. Amazing stone fireplace and wood stove insert. Eat-in kitchen w/breakfast bar, wood cabinets. LP forced air/ceiling ducts. Long driveway that opens up around the house and pond. You are surrounded by 56 acres of woodlands. Great location Copyright 2019 Elmira-Corning Regional Board of Realtors MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed
15 photos
$69,900 2.69 acres 3 Beds | 3 Baths | 2800 sqft
5306 Dutch Hill Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040 - Cortland County

2.69 acres Cincinnatus, NY

Finish your country dream home here. Home has been shelled in upstairs and nearly finished down. Offers a unique flare of living and some acreage to boot! The open floor plan in the living room and kitchen makes it great for entertainment and or family time. Upstairs one bedroom is complete but the other two area shelled out and the other two bathrooms are also ready for completion. See this diamond that isn't in the rough but needs your polishing today! Copyright 2019 Greater Syracuse Association of Realtors. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.
29 photos
$535,000 3.83 acres 6 Beds | 5 Baths | 7336 sqft
90 S Main Street, Homer, NY 13077 - Cortland County

3.83 acres Homer, NY

Extraordinary Italianate situated on 3.83 acres of private lawns, gardens & pool area in Homer Village. Enter through the double doors w/ elegant etched glass or side entry Portichere. Gourmet kitchen w/ center island & breakfast bar w/ adj. veranda. Gathering room, Butlers pantry w/ wet bar & beverage cooler makes for great entertaining. Private master suite w/ porcelain tile, double shower & walk-in closet. add'l 5 beds & 4 full baths. Front parlor w/ marble FP, adj. 4 season room w/ floor to ceiling windows & entry to patio & south lawn. 3rd floor stairway to Widows walk. Copyright 2019 Ithaca Board of Realtors. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and sho
18 photos
$85,000 1.4 acres 3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1456 sqft
3246 State Route 26, Cincinnatus, NY 13040 - Cortland County

1.4 acres Cincinnatus, NY

Welcome to this fantastic 3 bedroom 2 full bath country home located on over an acre. You are welcomed from the driveway into the oversized 2 car detached garage. Through the front door you will appreciate the open floor plan that consists of a formal dining area, spacious living room, and kitchen. Off the living room is the master bedroom with bath. The opposite wing of the house has 2 additional bedrooms, a full bath, and a large family room with gas stove. The laundry room couples as a mudroom and has a door that leads out to the large fenced yard. The sale also includes 3266 State Route 26 that has an older, but still functional single wide, and additional garage/outbuilding. Don't miss out on this fantastic opportunity. Copyright 2