Homes for sale in Cortland County New York | Page 1 of 5 | Country Homes of America
#1 in Rural Real Estate Online

Homes for sale in Cortland County New York - Page 1 of 5

19 photos
$154,900 55.93 acres
3501 McGraw Marathon Road, Mcgraw, NY 13101 - Cortland County

55 acres Amish Horse Farm in McGraw NY 3501 McGraw Road

Nice 55 acre Horse Farm with fenced pasture and a 30 x 60 barn in McGraw NY, Cortland County. Currently a working Amish Farm and includesa farmhouse and an outbuilding for a workshop. Large hay field and stream (Smith Brook). The farmhouse is currently without electric and consists of a large kitchen/dining room, a large living room and one bedroom downstairs. Upstairs there are three bedrooms. The property does have septic and two water sources. They currently use a spring located on a hill that uses natural water pressure with a holding tank. Never had any issues. There is also a cased, drilled well that hasn't been used in 4 years. Location: 3 miles from McGraw, NY 5 miles from I-81 Exit 10 7 miles from Cortland, NY 30 mil
Carl Snyder NY Land Quest, LLC
49 photos
$299,900 202 acres
Carr Road, Willet, NY 13863 - Cortland County

202 acres Farmland and Woodlands in Willet NY

escription 202 acres deer hunters paradise land for sale with great location for country home, retreat and country estate. Ideal house and livestock country. Approximately 47 acres of tillable and pasture with three separate fields joined by a woods road (loaded with oaks and acorns) and separated by hedgerows. Tons of apple trees along the edge of fields. Incredible views with several building sites overlooking nothing but countryside (rolling hills, farms and tree-lines). Perfect location for homesteading, hobby farming, growing hops, tree orchard and incredible for a sportsman looking for the best mix of cover, food and privacy. Exceptional hunting for whitetail, turkey and small game. This property is loaded with wildlife! Severa
Pete Martino New York Outdoor Realty
40 photos
$399,900 245.8 acres 1 ½ Bath | 864 sqft
Owego Hill Road, Harford, NY 13784 - Cortland County

245 acres Log Cabin Waterfall Lodge

Gorgeous Retreat -- Waterfall Lodge on 245+ acres in Harford NY, Cortland County. Lovely off-the-grid log cabin nestled in the hills south of Cortland, NY. Great acreage with a secluded Log Cabin. Has water, septic, propane, wood stove and a nice stone fireplace. Stocked pond and stream with a waterfall. 245+ acres and all of this! Gated access and a gravel drive take you well back into the property to a secluded log cabin. You hear NOTHING of the outside world. Tons of deer, turkey, and grouse with trails throughout. Just out the door is an amazing natural waterfall. Take the trail a couple of hundred yards to a deep stocked pond. Bass, bullhead, and panfish will share the water with you while you take a swim to cool off.
Carl Snyder NY Land Quest, LLC
24 photos
$114,900 8.09 acres 4 Beds | 1 Bath | 1464 sqft
1695 Route 221, Marathon, NY 13803 - Cortland County

8 acres House in Marathon NY 1695 Route 221

Lovely country home with 4 bedrooms on 8 acres with valley views in Cortland County. Hobby Farm? Horses? Could be certified organic. What a perfect location to raise a family and enjoy the outdoors! Plant vegetables, have animals or just enjoy country living. The exterior of this house is maintenance free with a metal roof and vinyl siding. The entire interior of the home was update by the seller. Large open kitchen, nice living room. An office, bedroom and bath on the first floor as well. Upstairs a large master and two more bedrooms. Notice the bright outdoor light shining through the windows. Country living at its finest. Nicely designed first floor with a private office space. Plenty of room. Efficiency is built into t
Carl Snyder NY Land Quest, LLC
1 photos
$79,900 45.42 acres
0 Jordan Road, Taylor, NY 13040 - Cortland County

45.42 acres Taylor, NY

If you are looking to build a seasonal get a way, this is the place you have been waiting for! Fantastic views, deer and turkeys make this place perfect for your off the grid home. 45 acres of partially wooded farmland and hunting land. Convenient location just minutes from Cincinnatus, NY-26, NY-41, and Greek Peak Mountain Resort. Nearby land offers many activities such as hiking, trout/ walleye fishing, hunting and kayaking. Beautiful valley views, multiple activities, and convenient location makes this property one you won't want to miss!
Allen Olmsted Canaan Realty
28 photos
$158,900 60.38 acres
U.S. 11, Homer, NY 13077 - Cortland County

60 acres 2 Stocked Lakes in Homer NY Route 11

Amazing Waterfront Land in Cortland County for your Fishing Retreat! 60+ acres Stocked Lakes Lovely acreage with two (former) gravel quarry pits that have been turned into amazing fisheries. Convenient to I-81/Homer in Cortland County. Private stocked lakes with a variety of freshwater fish. Spring fed. The possibilities on a property like this are endless. DEEP water lakes with depths from 20 to 30+ feet. A personal project in stewardship by current owner. Northern Pike, Largemouth Bass, Smallmouth Bass, Pumpkinseed Sunfish, Bluegill, Yellow Perch, Bullhead, Carp, and Brown Trout with several varieties of shiners and shad as well. 3,265 feet of waterfront on the West Branch of the Tioughnioga River. This unique property was
Carl Snyder NY Land Quest, LLC
21 photos
$164,900 99 acres
State Route 41, Cincinnatus, NY 13040 - Cortland County

99 Acres Tillable Farmland and Woodlands in Cincinnatus, NY

Have a look at this 99 acres in Cortland County located on Route 41. Mix of fields, woods and a nice year-round stream. Could be certified Organic. No sprays or chemicals used in 40 years. NICE area not hunted for many years! This property consists of 35-40 acres of fields, a lovely stream and 55-60 acres of woods. Currently leased, the tillable acreage is hay with one field used for corn periodically. Possible organic. The general area is rolling hills. Soil Maps are available as well. Walking this property was nice. I had deer all around me. There are some photos of a rub and trails. One photo has a few does in it in the distance. Turkeys, partridge and the likes are here as well. Amazing Stream runs through this property. Loo
Carl Snyder NY Land Quest, LLC
19 photos
$49,900 19 acres
McFarlane Road, Cincinnatus, NY 13040 - Cortland County

Farmland near Cortland NY with Views 19 acres

Lovely acreage in Cincinnatus NY, Cortland County with amazing views! Cleared hayfield and some woods to call your own. And, own your own hilltop with amazing views in upstate New York. These two parcels are situated to make the perfect building spot for your home or cabin. I cannot imagine waking up to these views. VERY quiet country road in a very quiet town. 20 minutes from Route 81/Exit 10 25 minutes from Cortland, NY 30 minutes from Norwich, NY 40 minutes from Binghamton, NY If you are searching for that property to build your home/cabin, this one may be the one. There are plenty of cleared places to stake out the future location with views in all directions. The topography is perfect! There is plenty of room for live
Carl Snyder NY Land Quest, LLC
6 photos
$238,900 211 acres
134 Chwalek Road, Richford, NY 13835 - Cortland County

211 acres Farmland and Timberland near Cortland NY

Acreage in Cortland County bordered on 3 sides by NYS Forest! This unique 211 acre property located at the end of a Town road includes mineral rights and there is no gas lease. The land is the site of a former homestead and includes a pole barn, 50+- acres that could be reclaimed farmland with the balance being woodland with trails throughout. This property is in a great historical location near the birthplace of John D. Rockefeller, located just west of the Route 81 corridor and the Village of Marathon. It is also an easy commute to the Cities of Ithaca, Cortland and Binghamton. The lay of the land allows for the property to be subdivided into several lots all bordering the NYS Forest. Priced to sell at $238,900.
Carl Snyder NY Land Quest, LLC
17 photos
$59,900 38.5 acres
Daisy Hollow Road, Virgil, NY 13045 - Cortland County

Farmland near Dryden NY with Trout Stream 38 Acres

38 acres in the Town of Virgil close to Greek Peak Ski Mountain. Located in the Town of Virgil just fifteen minutes from Dryden and less than a half hour from Ithaca and Cornell University, sits this perfect country parcel. Stocked with trout, Virgil Creek meanders through the property providing excellent fishing opportunities and great habitat for large and small game. Youll find extensive frontage on two town maintained roads that will take you to Greek Peak Ski Mountain as well as Kennedy and Tuller Hill State Forests just a short country drive away. If you have dreams of building a home and keeping horses or having a mini farm, then you need not look any further! Theres a perfect open meadow with pasture and tillable ground th
Carl Snyder NY Land Quest, LLC
16 photos
$49,500 15.07 acres
3469 Hubbards Hill Road, Taylor, NY 13040 - Cortland County

15.07 acres Taylor, NY

Spacious recreational property with an existing camp on site. Ideal for a getaway destination, hunting, and fishing. Off the grid property ideal for solitude! A small frog pond and acres of woods enhance this relaxing property.
Allen Olmsted Canaan Realty
4 photos
$39,900 25.05 acres
Lincklaen Rd, Truxton, NY 13158 - Cortland County

Southern Tier Home or Camp Site

Open, rolling meadows with woodlands all around, this property is located on a quiet, maintained town road with power available. This 25 acre parcel would make a nice site to build a country home or getaway for city dwellers. Close to Mariposa, Peage Hill and Cuyler Hill State Forests for southern tier hunting and hiking. Also within an hours drive to Syracuse, Ithaca, Cazenovia and the Finger Lakes region.
Daniel Christmas Christmas and Associates
45 photos
$385,000 122 acres 5 Beds | 2 Baths | 2000 sqft
1490 McGraw Marathon Road, Marathon, NY 13803 - Cortland County

Cortland County Gentleman's Dairy Farm

Cortland County 122+/- acres by survey Dairy/Gentlemans Farm. 80 acres tillable with good soils that could certify organic. Balance mostly high tensile pasture, some woods. Nice little 2 story 40 stall barn with a drive in mow. Set up for milking. Nice remodeled 2 story 6 bdrm home with 2 bth. Awesome location and beautiful setting. Mins from I81 Cortland. Syracuse, Binghamton all within minutes. Reduced from $425,000 to $385,000
Kara Posson Reed Posson Realty LLC
19 photos
$498,000 180 acres 4 Beds | 2 Baths
32194 Haines Rd, Cincinnatus, NY 13040 - Cortland County

Must see property

180 acre farm located in Cortland County NY. It is on a quiet and secluded dead end road, that is maintained by the town year round. Farm consists of 115 tillable, 25 pasture, 40 wooded. Included are three large barns consisting of an older dairy barn, a freestall/equipment storage barn, a large building for equipment/hay storage with heated shop, and a 20'x30' horse barn with 3-box stalls along with 2-box stalls in newer addition of dairy barn. Large open fields, stream, 1-acre pond, stone walls and woods are perfect for recreation, or livestock. Riding trails throughout property. The 4-bedroom, 2-bath newer raised ranch home is well maintained and has central A/C and central oil hot air heat, and has an outdoor wood boiler heat system. Fa
Scott Gerni United Country New York Real Estate & Auctions
33 photos
$105,900 0.52 acres 5 Beds | 2 Baths | 1792 sqft
187 Tompkins Street, Cortland, NY 13045 - Cortland County

0.52 acres Cortland, NY

You will feel right at "home" the moment you step into the formal entry of this well cared for property with lots of natural woodwork.FIRST FLOOR:Spacious LR;Eat-in kitchen w/pantry & side and back entry;Formal DR;#1 BR w/incredible walk-in shower/sink & FHA or electric BB heat.SECOND FLOOR: Full Bath;(4) BR;Walk up attic - great storage !! Full basement w/washer-dryer hookups and 50 gallon water tank. UPDATES BY THE OWNER: Brand NEW RUGS, Roof - 2 yrs old, Chimney -1 yr old, vinyl replacement windows-(1/2) done 7 yrs ago & half done 3 yrs ago,laminate floors installed-2 yrs ago, DR drywalled completely - 3 yrs ago,pool & deck-5 yrs old. Storage shed stays. Very deep back yard - great for play and plantings. Minutes to SUNY, shopping and ma
28 photos
$164,900 2.2 acres 4 Beds | 3 Baths | 2350 sqft
6399 West Scott Road, Scott, NY 13077 - Cortland County

2.2 acres Scott, NY

This home has it all, MUST SEE! Completely remodeled ranch nestled into a perfect country setting. Spacious kitchen & living room, kitchen island w/custom concrete counters- perfect for entertaining! Brand new flooring & carpet throughout, new master bathroom with barn style doors. Bonus rooms/additional bedrooms downstairs with additional full bath. Cozy screened in porch with well-built wrap around deck. HUGE barn in large yard with majestic view of the mountains. You're own private retreat!
30 photos
$399,900 8.83 acres 4 Beds | 4 Baths | 1 ½ Bath | 2350 sqft
2361 S CORTLAND VIRGIL RD, Virgil, NY 13045 - Cortland County

8.83 acres Virgil, NY

A Modern Manor--close to conveniences with over 8.5 acres of privacy. Luxuriate in the cook's kitchen, entertain on the lavish grounds around your spring-fed pond, enjoy the formal living and dining rooms, and relax in the den with a "wall of windows" to enjoy the amazing views. 4 generous bedrooms, 3.5 baths, and top-of-the-line finishings. Murano glass lighting in the breakfast nook, a stunning master bathroom with terrific views from the jetted tub, red oak floors, silk damask wallcovering in the half bath, multi-level decks, a pool nestled in a rock wall lined with lavendar, and even an ou
35 photos
$159,900 6.79 acres 3 Beds | 3 Baths | 1 ½ Bath | 2200 sqft
3623 State Route 41 Road, Solon, NY 13040 - Cortland County

6.79 acres Solon, NY

Welcome to the Country! Beautiful well maintained ranch situated on 6.79 acres featuring a cabin overlooking a beautiful tranquil pond. This ranch offers 2200 SQFT of living space with incredible views of the property right from inside. The front foyer welcomes you into the house opening up into an immaculate open kitchen with cathedral ceilings and exposed beams, great for entertaining guest. Adjacent to the kitchen is a very bright formal dining room with exposed beams and built in storage. Across from the dining room is second entry that welcomes you into a spacious living room surrounded with windows and Sliding glass doors leading to the back deck overlooking the property. The main level of the home includes 3 bedrooms and 1.5 bathroo
23 photos
$164,900 2 acres 3 Beds | 3 Baths | 2350 sqft
6399 W Scott Rd., Scott, NY 13077 - Cortland County

2 acres Scott, NY

This home has is all, MUST SEE! Completely remodeled ranch nestled into the perfect country setting. Spacious kitchen & living room, kitchen island w/ custom concrete counters- perfect for entertaining! Brand new flooring & carpet throughout, new master bathroom with barn style doors. Bonus rooms downstairs with additional full bath. Cozy screened in porch with wrap around deck. HUGE barn, over sized yard & views of the mountains. Homer School District.
36 photos
$410,000 5.54 acres 6 Beds | 4 Baths | 1 ½ Bath | 7400 sqft
5042 Forbes Road, Homer, NY 13045 - Cortland County

5.54 acres Homer, NY

This contemporary home will WOW you with the use of space and views. Home offers the space a family can never grow out of. The main doors welcome you into a giant entertainment space with kitchen, dining, and living room combination. A private study, three bedrooms, 2 full baths also on this same floor. Huge loft space great for a rec room or family room. If this isn't enough the lower level offers another great open space, 2-3 more bedrooms and 1.5 baths. Home offers floor to ceiling windows for great lighting, 3-bay garage, fiberglass in-ground pool and a separate home with full kitchen, bath, bed and living room. Perfect as an in-law suite or pool house.
16 photos
$149,995 1.77 acres 3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1976 sqft
1163 & 1177 Gallagher Road Road, Cortland, NY 13045 - Cortland County

1.77 acres Cortland, NY

House and land just south of Cortland City. Two tax parcels being sold as one transaction. Includes 0.77-acre lot with a 1,976 sq. ft., doublewide manufactured home built in 1999, and a 2-car garage and a separate 1-acre lot with well and septic system. Huge living room. Large family room. Master bedroom with master bathroom and walk-in closet. Dining room is currently being used as a 3rd bedroom. New plumbing in the kitchen and master bathroom. Three decks from which to enjoy the outdoors. Convenient to both Ithaca and Cortland City. Abuts the Willowbrook Golf Club. Being sold as one transaction with a partially forested 14-acre backyard for rural recreation (which is listed separately).
19 photos
$179,900 15.86 acres 3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1976 sqft
1163 Gallagher Road, Cortland, NY 13045 - Cortland County

15.86 acres Cortland, NY

Country estate just south of Cortland City. Three tax parcels being sold as one transaction. Includes a 1,976 sq. ft., doublewide manufactured home built in 1999, a 2-car garage, 1-acre lot with well and septic system, and 15.86 acres of partially forested land with a small stream. (Not in a flood zone.) Huge living room. Large family room. Master bedroom with master bathroom and walk-in closet. Dining room is currently being used as a 3rd bedroom. Water purifier. Three decks to enjoy the outdoors from. Partially forested 14-acre backyard for rural recreation. Convenient to both Ithaca
29 photos
$515,000 1.09 acres 2 Beds | 1 Bath | 1071 sqft
7490 Fair Haven Road, Scott, NY 13077 - Cortland County

1.09 acres Scott, NY

Incredible opportunity to own a piece of history, gorgeous level east side lakefront and a wonderful lake house w/potential for another guest house. Formerly know as Shady Beach Marina, this property is located on the SE end of Skaneateles Lake. The level lakefront lot includes a permanent dock surrounding the entire lot, a private boat launch, moorings for a boat & swim float & a shed w/compost toilet. The updated cottage offers unobstructed, panoramic lakeviews, a new deck, huge sleeping porch, 2 large bedrooms, newly remodeled bathroom, laundry, full walkout lower level offering additional living space & a brand new roof. The house to the south has been gutted offers incredible potential. This is a perfect vacation, investment opportuni
34 photos
$189,900 0.81 acres 6 Beds | 3 Baths | 2124 sqft
143 N West Street, Homer, NY 13077 - Cortland County

0.81 acres Homer, NY

Village living with feel of country! So many rooms you can get lost!! Freshly painted formal DR with beauty natural woodwork and a den/office/BR off of it. Kitchen has corian counters with an island sink and lots of pantry space. 1st flr master with full bath. Large LR with another BR off of it. 1st Flr laundry and 2nd full bath with claw foot tub. Back entry is a sunroom offering additional 3 season living space was used for dining area. Upstairs has 3 more BRs and full bath with jetted tub. Outside you have a beautiful in-ground pool and gardens. 2 car garage has workshop and 2nd story storage. THEN there is the original barn that would make a great studio, more storage or you name it!!. Beautiful park-like yard and let's not forget a fr
26 photos
$64,900 0.82 acres 2 Beds | 1 Bath | 720 sqft
3312 Clute Road, Cortland, NY 13045 - Cortland County

0.82 acres Cortland, NY

Country living in the small Hamlet of Blodgett Mills. Looking for your first starter home? Many options for this great 1-2 bedroom single wide on a full basement with closed in porch. 2 car garage, plenty of lawn for gardening, playing sports, Barbeques, picnics, or just relaxing. Only minutes from town.
23 photos
$210,000 0.98 acres 4 Beds | 3 Baths | 1 ½ Bath | 2552 sqft
4079 Highland Road, Cortland, NY 13045 - Cortland County

0.98 acres Cortland, NY

Sprawling hillside Colonial on a double lot for added privacy. Four bedrooms includes the Master Suite with full bath. Two fireplaces with one in the partially finished basement. First floor laundry. Hardwood floors. Abundant storage throughout including large second floor walk in closet. Beautiful views and rear deck to enjoy the wild life. Convenient location close to shopping, services, Rte 81 and Ithaca.
12 photos
$174,900 1.44 acres 5 Beds | 3 Baths | 2917 sqft
3480 STATE ROUTE 215, Cortland, NY 13045 - Cortland County

1.44 acres Cortland, NY

Charming 5BR / 3BA all original 1960's cape on 1.44 beautiful acres. 3BR/2BA on main level including master suite, EIK, formal dining, laundry, and living room with wood stove insert in a beautifully tiled fireplace mantle. Upstairs features two oversized bedrooms and a full bath. The concrete basement downstairs provides plenty of space for a workshop area. Outside the home enjoy a beautiful hillside vibrant with lilacs, Rose of Sharon, Pin Cherry and Crab Cherry trees from the comfort of your front porch. Enjoy this picturesque setting just minuets from downtown. Convenient,private, spacious
14 photos
$79,900 4.6 acres 4 Beds | 4 Baths | 1 ½ Bath | 1594 sqft
5947 Webb Road, Willet, NY 13863 - Cortland County

4.6 acres Willet, NY

Four Bedroom contemporary property on 4.6 acres waiting for new owners to make it a home. Features include 1594 sq ft, first floor bedroom, a stone fireplace in the living room, two full baths, back patio and private setting. Home needs some TLC and requires cash or rehab/construction loan. Sold as-is.
16 photos
$349,999 21.34 acres 3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1340 sqft
5008 Health Camp Rd, Homer, NY 13077 - Cortland County

21.34 acres Homer, NY

Spectacular newer construction 3 bedroom/2 bath energy efficient ranch home on over 21 acres! Horse lovers paradise!! Open concept eat in kitchen looks into the living room & out the sliding doors.Fabulous master suite w/ huge tiled walk in shower & walk in closet!!Guest bath has spacious jacuzzi tub.Mudroom entry from the attached 2 car garage.Separate 28 x 32 heated shop/garage & separate 14 x 32 pole barn. 52 x 46 horse barn w/full hay storage & tack room. Feed room 14 x 30. Pasture 10 acres w/high tensile fencing.10 acres of woods w/riding trails! Perfect for snowmobiles & 4 wheelers!
17 photos
$154,900 26.52 acres 2 Beds | 1 Bath | 624 sqft
04701 Cheningo Solon Pond Road, Taylor, NY 13040 - Cortland County

26.52 acres Taylor, NY

Cozy cabin on a hill with an open front porch where you can take in the amazing views. This home with extra decorative touches enjoys an open kitchen-living area with cathedral ceilings, first floor bedroom, bath and laundry along with a loft bedroom. Besides the baseboard heat there is an efficient soapstone wood stove to keep you warm on cold nights. A 28 x 40 ft pole barn comes complete with a concrete floor to store your toys, tools and cars. 26 acres of open meadow and woods complete with a natural spring. The front meadow is wire fenced for horses if that suits your wants or needs. If you are looking for a newer, comfortable home with privacy, this is the place! More pictures coming soon