Homes for sale in Sullivan County New York | Page 1 of 26 | Country Homes of America
CountryHomesofAmerica.com
#1 in Rural Real Estate Online

Homes for sale in Sullivan County New York - Page 1 of 26

31 photos
Featured
$3,750,000 828 acres
5 Steges Rd, Eldred, NY 12732 - Sullivan County

Private Lake on 800+ Acres!

This is an exceptional offering for the most discerning buyers. Private Lake with large frontage on a gorgeous property in a very desirable location! This RARE find and very unique opportunity is suitable for many ventures. Entire listing includes multiple lots compiling 820+ acres and a private lake with waterfall and gorgeous stone arch dam superbly situated in the western part of the Sullivan County Catskills. Two houses (rented) and a small cabin on the lake are part of the package. Stunning waterfront property is gently rolling, level and very accessible with a huge amount (over 2 miles) of road frontage on two roads. Lots of character with evergreen and deciduous trees, mostly wooded and some cleared, and many possible building sites.
Carol Malek Malek Properties
10 photos
Featured
$2,250,000 853.12 acres
Pine Grove Road, White Lake, NY 12786 - Sullivan County

Fabulous Forest in Desirable Bethel New York

Amazing location, amazing property and AMAZING Price!!! 853.12 surveyed acres of undeveloped property nestled between two sought-after communities in Bethel. Backing the exclusive gated Chapin Estate on one side and Smallwood Lake Community on the other this is a very rare find. Hemp Meadow Brook meanders through part and property is wooded and generally sloping, level and tiered. Beautiful large boulders, exquisite mature woodland and fantastic hiking, hunting, recreation land. Awesome development possibilities, the 14 parcels are zoned Forest Conservation requiring 5 acres per residence. Moments from Toronto Reservoir, White Lake, Swinging Bridge Lake, Lake Superior Park and Bethel Woods Center for the Arts and Museum. Near to restaurants
Carol Malek Malek Properties
11 photos
$74,900 5.14 acres
41 Summit Dr, Eldred, NY 12792 - Sullivan County

Timber Lake Building Lot - Catskills

Located less than two hours from the George Washington Bridge, this five acre buildable lot with access to a private lake is a rare find. This beautiful parcel, located in the private gated community of Timber Lake Estates, would make the perfect spot for a year round country home or summer getaway. An approved septic plan is already in place and the wooded property includes deeded access to Timber Lake a private, non-motor boat, mountain lake. You can swim, fish, kayak or sail and a sandy beach plus picnic area is shared by only a handful of community residents. Timber Lake Estates is private and gated for your security. Its close to town for schools, shopping, banking and more! The property is only five minutes from the Delaware River a
Daniel Christmas Christmas and Associates
18 photos
$329,500 8.76 acres
0 Plank Road, Forestburg, NY 12777 - Sullivan County

8.76 acres Forestburg, NY

Large acreage building site located in one of the areas most desirable locations! The property backs up to Swinging Bridge Reservoir, with potential floating dock access to this beautiful non-motorized boat lake. The surrounding areas high-end homes and seclusion enhances this ideal getaway site.
Allen Olmsted Canaan Realty
27 photos
$264,000 0.51 acres 3 Beds | 2 Baths | 2147 sqft
154 Rockland Road, Roscoe, NY 12776 - Sullivan County

154 Rockland Rd

1890 Farmhouse. Remarkably preserved with updates. Hardwood floors with character and charm. Eat in kitchen, formal dining room, living room and family room. Gorgeous brick fireplace. Stylish and functional kitchen with adorable cabinets. Corner lazy susan, roll out cabinet draws and tons of storage space for appliances and gadgets. Windows and porch overlooking the first fairway at Twin Village Golf course. Walking distance to legendary fishing on the Beaverkill River. Updates include tiled floors in the bathrooms. Oversized two car garage with enclosed breezeway to the home. This farmhouse also has closets-bedroom closets, cedar lined closets, linen closet, pantry closet, coat closet in the breezeway(heated). Looking to entertain-three re
Eagle River Realty, LLC Eagle River Realty, LLC
49 photos
$425,000 3.63 acres 5 Beds | 2 Baths | 1 ½ Bath | 2816 sqft
340 Hessinger and Lare Road, Livingston Manor, NY 12758 - Sullivan County

5 Bedroom Colonial

Large Colonial style home set back from road with a private, wooded view. Close to Monticello Motor Club, Bethel Woods, Resorts World Casino, Villa Roma, hunting, fishing, and ski areas. 5 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms, plus full walk-up insulated and unfinished attic. Master Suite with walk-in closet, Master bath with jacuzzi tub. Large eat-in kitchen with island and all stainless steel appliances. New electric range. Large family room with wood log fireplace, formal dining room, Living room, upstairs laundry room, and full unfinished basement with bilco doors. Full front porch and split-level rear deck with pergola and electric retractable awning. Attached heated 2-car garage plus detached garage/workshop and detached steel carport. Additional
Mary Lanzillotti
11 photos
$199 0.26 acres
Willow Lane, Thompson, NY 12701 - Sullivan County

Live a Serene Life, $199/month, Everyone Qualifies, Satisfaction Guarantee

We finance! No Credit Check, Great Guarantees, Portion of Sale Goes to Charity, Same-Day Purchase, A+ rating with BBB. Brokers/Realtors welcome; will pay commission. 0.26 Acres Thompson, Sullivan County, NY Payment Plan / Seller Financing: - $199 per month for 57 months (plus $99 Earnest Money / Processing Fee) - $500 Down - 0% Interest, No Credit Check - Once your first payment is made, the land is yours to use and enjoy while you make payments - No cancellation or prepayment penalties! Single Payment: - $9,997 (plus $99 Earnest Money / Processing Fee) - Save $1,943 compared to financed price! - Or Give Us Your Best Offer! Parcel #: 62.-1-10.1 Street: Willow Lane
Craig Kahn TruDream Properties, LLC
11 photos
$199 0.26 acres
Hemlock Lane, Thompson, NY 12701 - Sullivan County

In a Quaint Neighborhood, $199/month, All Qualify, Text for $250 Off.

We finance! No Credit Check, Great Guarantees, Portion of Sale Goes to Charity, Same-Day Purchase, A+ rating with BBB. Brokers/Realtors welcome; will pay commission. 0.26 Acres Thompson, Sullivan County, NY Payment Plan / Seller Financing: - $199 per month for 57 months (plus $99 Earnest Money / Processing Fee) - $500 Down - 0% Interest, No Credit Check - Once your first payment is made, the land is yours to use and enjoy while you make payments - No cancellation or prepayment penalties! Single Payment: - $9,997 (plus $99 Earnest Money / Processing Fee) - Save $1,943 compared to financed price! - Or Give Us Your Best Offer! Parcel #: 62.-1-13 Street: Hemlock Lane
Craig Kahn TruDream Properties, LLC
56 photos
$5,900,000 67 acres 4 Beds | 3 Baths | 1 ½ Bath | 6000 sqft
398 Claryville Road, Claryville, NY 12725 - Sullivan County

Claryville Estate

A one of a kind luxury country estate located in coveted Claryville, NY on 67 park like acres. Built on one of the oldest 3 generation family fly fishing camps in the Catskill Mountains,this compound provides the comforts of a 5 star resort in a natural yet sophisticated setting. The enclave consists of the 6,000 sq ft main house,1,300+ sq ft guest house,60'x40' (2,400 sq ft) storage garage and a 40'x30 (1200 sq ft) stable.The main and guest houses are constructed of large hand-hewn Douglas Fir logs from British Columbia. The 2 outbuildings are authentic mortise and tendon structures, representing superb craftsmanship while reminiscent of a time gone by. Reclaimed timber from this property was used for their construction. All of this is cen
Alla Sienitsky Resort Realty
36 photos
$599,900 48.6 acres 5 Beds | 3 Baths | 2396 sqft
335 Weissman Road, Livingston Manor, NY 12758 - Sullivan County

335 Weissman Road Livingston Manor, NY 12758

Pristine, private and preserved... a piece of history lives in this classic early 1860's farmhouse that married an addition in 1920 and has been tastefully remodeled and updated without compromising that "Down on the Farm" charm. Almost 50 acres of amazing property is a picturesque bucolic setting with open fields, woods, seasonal stream, natural landscaping, mature trees, blueberries, stone walls, and gorgeous mountain vistas. This sprawling country home offers 5+ BR's, including Master suite with skylights, 3 full BA's, gourmet chef's kitchen, second kitchen/studio, LR, family room, mudroom and "fun" finished attic. Wide plank floors, hand-hewn beams, built-ins, and quintessential country accents throughout. Very efficient updates include
Carol Malek Malek Properties
24 photos
$250,000 0.58 acres 1 Bed | 1 Bath | 440 sqft
106 Lake Muskoday Road, Roscoe, NY 12776 - Sullivan County

110 Lake Muskoday

Almost new cabin on Lake Muskoday. Your getaway that has it all. Quiet serenity, mountain and water views. Fishing, paddling, swimming hiking and biking right here. Beautiful tongue and groove pine great room. Cathedral ceiling, custom window coverings. Sleeping loft with views. Custom built cabinetry in the kitchen. Screened porch with mahogany floors. Bluestone patio and built in grill with "WOW" factor. Parking for guests and storage too. The fishing? Perch, large crappies, channel cats. pickerel and tremendous smallmouth bass. Opportunity to join the Homeowners Association and gain access to several hundred more acres which they own.
Eagle River Realty, LLC Eagle River Realty, LLC
48 photos
$220,000 33.14 acres 3 Beds | 2 Baths | 1536 sqft
181 Cattail Road, Livingston Manor, NY 12758 - Sullivan County

181 Cattail rd Livingston Manor

HUNTERS PARADISE!! Deer, fox ,bear, turkey all roaming on your 34 acres. Enter through your private gate to a long unpaved driveway leading to the completely secluded house. First view of the house shows that the outside needs painting, don't let that fool you the inside is in excellent condition. A coat of paint on the outside, some cosmetics on the inside is all it needs. Entering the house you come into the den, living room, kitchen as they are set up in an open floor plan.There are three bedrooms with the Master Suite occupying the entire third floor. The two other bedrooms are on the second floor. There is fourth room in the basement that has a wood stove and can be a family room. The garage is also accessed from the basement and holds
Eagle River Realty, LLC Eagle River Realty, LLC
9 photos
$219,000 11.5 acres
38 & 40 Karmel & Jacobs Rd, Loch Sheldrake, NY 12759 - Sullivan County

Maplewood Development land

Opportunity knocks. Attention developers 11.5 acres of property with the frontage on 2 roads, nice corner. Town water and sewer available. Zoning HR 1 which allow multifamily subdivision or town house development. Walk to town and lake. There are structures on the property being sold as is.
Alla Sienitsky Resort Realty
12 photos
$899,900 242 acres 2 Beds | 1 Bath | 1000 sqft
Monticello, NY 12701 - Sullivan County

Recreational property

Attention hunters!!! or interested party we can rent for the season!!!! Large parcel of property with 3 contiguous parcels with frontage and entrances on 3 roads and private lake. Fully functional and insulated Hunting cabin on one of the smaller parcels with the views of the lake. Some property is located in forestry. Best use is a private estate. Located just a couple of miles from the exit 106, the area of the major Las Vegas style Casino Resort development, stone throw from Monticello Motor Club. Rental Available for Hunting purposes $8000 a season.
Alla Sienitsky Resort Realty
6 photos
$159,900 45.55 acres
322 Heiden rd, Monticello, NY 12701 - Sullivan County

Monticello large parcel

Location, location! A CATSKILLS DESTINATION REBORN. In the back yard of the Las Vegas type casino/ resort Catskills World Resort and new water park opening in April 2019. Beautiful spot in the country, close to everything, but very rural. Land has tall trees, may have timber value of $$$. Long road frontage, may have a developmental value. Bring your enterprise or build your estate possible subdivision.
Alla Sienitsky Resort Realty
41 photos
$249,900 109 acres
NY-17B, White Lake, NY 12786 - Sullivan County

Nys Hwy 17b White Lake, NY 12786

Strategically positioned between 2 lakes this is an unbeatable opportunity. Commercially Zoned on the 17B State Hwy side, high visibility and extremely high traffic count, especially during concert season and summer months with second home-owners and tourism. Near White Lake for motor sports and many great restaurants. Located in the business district next to the post office, bank, Dollar General, Duncan Donuts, etc. The other side of the property has several points of access and is straddled around a club and a restaurant in the Smallwood Lake community. The White Lake Brook runs through the land and feeds Mountain Lake, the Smallwood community lake that is accessible only to residents and is no-motor with beach, dock, club, tennis, etc. G
Carol Malek Malek Properties
46 photos
$180,000 0.78 acres 4 Beds | 1 Bath | 1 ½ Bath | 1475 sqft
8 Church Lake Road, Livingston Manor, NY 12758 - Sullivan County

8 Church Lake Road

On a private road in the Lake community of Shandelee this Arts and Crafts house has been beautifully renovated with attention to architectural details. Interior features include original Maple woodwork, high ceilings, and hardwood floors throughout the house. There is plenty of room for everybody with 4 bedrooms, walk in closets and 1 and 1/2 baths. The kitchen features a walk in arts & craft pantry with shelving and cabinets made with the same wood used throughout the house, it's a one of a kind. The stairs lead to the office and three upstairs bedrooms. Outdoors there's a beautiful wrap around porch to enjoy meals on, relax while listening to the birds or just to sit back and read a book on a rainy day. There's a deck off the kitchen for
Eagle River Realty, LLC Eagle River Realty, LLC
36 photos
$499,900 27 acres 3 Beds | 2 Baths
88 Le Roy Road, Loch Sheldrake, NY 12759 - Sullivan County

88 Le Roy Loch Sheldrake, NY 12759

Beautiful 27 acre property offers level and rolling pastures, mature trees, stone walls and amazing mountain views. This land is strategically situated abutting the Sullivan County Community College property on two sides. It also has access to Rt. 52 and municipal water and sewer. Located at the end of a dead offers privacy and enhances the options for this gorgeous bucolic parcel. Used as a poultry farm for many years, this is a perfect place for numerous possible farming projects. Renovate the old 1900's farmhouse or build a new home, or several... The terrific location makes it a perfect opportunity for rural, educational, agricultural and/ or residential development. 3 BR, 2 Bath farmhouse and outbuildings are secondary to this prime pi
Carol Malek Malek Properties
28 photos
$369,900 49.73 acres 3 Beds | 3 Baths | 2450 sqft
1590 Old Route 17, Roscoe, NY 12776 - Sullivan County

1590 Old Route 17 Roscoe, NY 12776

This is a unique offering in Roscoe, Trout Town, USA, available with 49+ acres or the full 138 acres. Country home offers 3 BR's, 3 BA's, old-style charm with some upgrades. Interior boasts warm woodwork, tiled baths, wood stove, and large enclosed porch. Detached 3 car garage and shed are a great asset. Property is mostly wooded with miles of trails. There are springs on the property as well as a babbling brook. Across the street is the Willoweemoc Creek for excellent trout fishing. Property is just about a mile off the exit for a quick commute, and is easily accessible to downtown Roscoe and minutes to Livingston Manor for more adventures, shopping, and dining, etc. Terrific property for recreational use, ATV's, hunting, hiking, snowmobil
Carol Malek Malek Properties
5 photos
$26,000 25.95 acres
State Route 209, Phillipsport, NY 12769 - Sullivan County

Recreational land with streams

Great buy. 25.95 acres in 3 parcels on state hwy and country rd, on Homowack kill, 2 streams come together on the property, country and mountains views, corner lot of state route 209 and Doolittle both sides, small corner piece across. great for recreation, hunting, may have some commercial value on Route 209.
Alla Sienitsky Resort Realty
35 photos
$349,900 103.75 acres
Bowers Road, Hurleyville, NY 12747 - Sullivan County

Bowers Road Hurleyville, NY 12747

Rare opportunity to get 100+ acres in this beautiful scenic location. Mostly wooded with some open fields this property is the perfect fit for a country estate, for private recreation and in addition is prime for development. Some high points get beautiful views. Access consists of two points of road frontage on Bowers Road and property starts at the end of Bowers Drive. This beautiful 103+ acres is located in the Tri-Valley School district and is near to the Neversink Reservoir for exceptional boating and fishing. Some engineering has been done for possible subdivision, feasibility study, as well as preliminary subdivision map. See associated docs. Resort World Casino is ~30 minutes away, Bethel Woods Center for the Arts is also in close p
Carol Malek Malek Properties
7 photos
$79,900 20 acres
Forest road, Grahamsville, NY 12740 - Sullivan County

Watershed acreage, low tax area

Wooded acreage on the quiet road, lowest taxes in the area. Located in the Catskills Park by Rondout and Neversink reservoirs. Watershed,close to state and city lands, possible subdivision with the road cut in or great site for the house, recreation.
Alla Sienitsky Resort Realty
32 photos
$2,300,000 660 acres 4 Beds | 2 Baths
1056 Hunter Road, Neversink, NY 12765 - Sullivan County

Fly Fishing Haven on the Neversink River

Sportsman's Paradise! Over 650 acres of pristine woodland, abundant wildlife, open fields, orchards, natural springs, ponds and +/- of a mile of the famed Neversink River running through it. This section of the Neversink River has been recognized as one of the best fly fishing stretches in the Northeast. The property has one of the most attractive and historic fly-fishing rivers running through it (making it your own private fishing spot) with plentiful trout and local land-locked salmon. This section of the fabled Neversink River has been recognized as one of the best, has been fished by some of the most famous fly fishermen (including Hewitt and Gordon), and has been featured in books and magazines. Included in this unique offering is a
Carol Malek Malek Properties
12 photos
$95,000 3.78 acres 2 Beds | 1 Bath | 1003 sqft
19 Foss Road, Monticello, NY 12701 - Sullivan County

Home and Gardens

space, 2 bedrooms, 1 full bath, eat in kitchen and cozy living room, 275 sq ft addition with wood stove, the rest of the home have forced air heat. All new windows, doors, new water heater and water pressure tank. Comfortable back deck for your enjoyment. Detached 1 car garage with electric, shed, fenced gardens, berries, fruit trees. Very unique lightly wooded piece of property, sandy soil, fire pit. Perfect for mini farm, vacation home or year round residence.
Alla Sienitsky Resort Realty
7 photos
$69,900 13.89 acres
Tuttle Hill Road, Livingston Manor, NY 12758 - Sullivan County

Blueberry hill property

A place in the country, nearly 14 acres of open fields and lightly wooded land with a country views. Enjoy wild flowers and blueberry bushes. Best uses are a home site, small farm, or simply camping. Located on a dead end road with plenty of privacy and minutes to the hwy and short distance to the village of Livingston Manor a well known for shops, restaurants, historic school, Shandalee music festival, Catskill Park, state land and hunting, hiking, fishing.
Alla Sienitsky Resort Realty
10 photos
$159,500 78.1 acres
Swamp Pond Road, Narrowsburg, NY 12764 - Sullivan County

CATSKILL MOUNTAINS - 78 ACRES BROOK LAKE

Heavily wooded 78 acre land tract with brook and trails traversing property. Frontage on township road. Easy access and rights to private mountain lake. Very private yet only minutes to charming river town.
John Schmitt Davis R. Chant Realtors
29 photos
$724,000 91.86 acres 4 Beds | 2 Baths | 1820 sqft
580 Horseshoe Lake Road, Swan Lake, NY 12783 - Sullivan County

580 Horseshoe Lake Road Swan Lake, NY 12783

Rare offering! 91.86 acres in desirable Town of Bethel with enormous road frontage! Classic 1940’s brick house is nestled among pristine and level woodland with huge potential and many options. Property straddles both sides of the road making an easy choice for subdivision, family compound, recreation or the perfect hunters’ paradise. Directly abutting a forever-wild reserve, this is home to abundant wildlife: rabbits, deer, turkey, bear, and more. Kauneonga Lake’s popular Restaurant Row and the historic 1969 Woodstock festival site, now Bethel Woods Performing Arts Center & Museum, is under 5 minutes away making this an even sweeter spot! Home offers a great place to hang your hat while you get away from the hustle and bu
Carol Malek Malek Properties
33 photos
$224,900 11.6 acres 4 Beds | 2 Baths | 1428 sqft
244 Co Rd 56, Wurtsboro, NY 12790 - Sullivan County

244 County Rd 56 Wurtsboro, NY 12790-3101

First time offered! Adorable Cape Cod style home in the country is set back from the road on 11.6 acres and is located in a terrific location with easy access for commuters. Hardwood floors, 4 BR, 2 baths, open plan kitchen DR/LR makes for comfy living. Walk out full basement offers plenty of space for workshop, playroom, storage, etc. Back door leads to huge deck overlooking your beautiful property. Land is open and lightly wooded, with garden area and small shed as well as plenty of room to roam. Fruit trees, deciduous and evergreens, and semi private from neighbors.
Carol Malek Malek Properties
14 photos
$349,000 112 acres
Glen Wild, NY 12701 - Sullivan County

Fantastic Hunting Ground! 112 Acres, Sullivan County, New York

One of our favorite types of properties with an interior slightly overgrown field (8+/- acres), lots of late bearing apple trees, mixed woodland age classes, and some scattered oak saw timber in the back 40. Near the field the woodlands have lots of thickets of High Bush Blueberry. A section across the street has some apple trees, good cover and a small stream. Travel on Route 17 Rockhill Exit to Glen Wild Road. Look for signs. For additional information, please contact Tom Dziekan, Agent, at (315) 789-3181 (office) or (315) 744-0904 (cell).
Farmers National Company Farmers National Company
29 photos
$364,900 48.2 acres 4 Beds | 2 Baths | 1981 sqft
23 Kieferle Rd, Eldred, NY 12732 - Sullivan County

8-23 Kieferle Road Eldred, NY 12732-5017

Completely private setting with beautiful large fishing pond, 2 cottages each with water views, 5 stall horse barn, huge machine garage, sheds, paddock, and lovely woodland with abundant wildlife is offered as one awesome package. The perfect combination for family compound, farm, hunting club or private estate with a guest cottage, there are so many options! Property consists of three separate parcels. 2 BR 1059 SF house with full bath, EIK, LR and enclosed porch overlooking water, is currently occupied and in good condition. This cute home offers deck, wood-stove and garage and is set on separate 2 acre parcel which includes part of the pond. The adorable 1939 922 SF cottage is a handyman indeed, but has great potential with stone firepla
Carol Malek Malek Properties